So far in 2016, commercial partner, Zambon has launched Xadago (safinamide) as an add-on therapy to Levodopa in mid-to-late Parkinson’s disease, in three additional territories (Italy, Switzerland and Spain). In the seven months following its launch in Germany in May 2015, Newron received €0.5m in royalties on product sales; given that we assume a 12% royalty rate this implies net sales of c €4m in Germany. The royalties were slightly lower than our €0.8m forecast; however, it remains early days and thus our Xadago forecasts remain unchanged. Xadago pricing in Germany is at a 40-60% premium to its closest comparable, Teva Pharmaceutical’s Azilect . This suggests to us that health authorities in Germany recognise that Xadago can offer advantages over Azilect (including long-term benefits), which should also aid with physician and patient uptake. We expect the roll-out of Xadago to continue in additional EU countries, as pricing and reimbursement are agreed in the coming months/quarters.
Our current forecasts and valuation assume that Xadago is priced broadly in line with Azilect outside Germany, leading to peak sales of c €450m based on a 10% penetration of the PD patient market. If Xadago can achieve premium pricing to Azilect across Europe and the US, as it has in Germany so far, then all else being equal our peak sales forecast would be closer to €660m. This would contribute a further CHF160m to our valuation, or CHF12/share. Until further pricing is agreed, particularly in the US, we make no changes to our forecasts at this stage.
Xadago remains under review in the US with a PDUFA decision date of 29 March 2016; Zambon continues to focus on sublicensing Xadago in this region with a deal potentially this year, on which Newron is entitled to a share of upfront and milestone payments, in addition to royalties. Zambon does not have a significant presence in the US, hence sublicensing Xadago will be key to maximising its potential. Furthermore, as highlighted in a previous publication (26 March 2015 Progression, partnering and prioritisation) we believe further studies investigating Xadago in dyskinesia associated with PD could form part of any potential sub-licensing deal(s). A label expansion detailing an improvement in dyskinesia with Xadago use could allow for potentially earlier use of L-dopa in PD and expand the market opportunity for safinamide. We include a risk-adjusted contribution for safinamide in dyskinesia, assuming peak sales of €350m until there is more clarity on the potential magnitude of benefit. It is estimated that dyskinesia affects around 40% of PD patients treated with L-dopa for four to six years, with limited treatment options aside from the L-dopa dosing adjustment. With around one million PD patients in each of the US and Europe, this therefore represents a large opportunity. We assume the safinamide label could be expanded to include dyskinesia following a single clinical trial, which could potentially start once approval has been granted in the US. We have updated our valuation for a potential label expansion to 2020 (vs 2018), however, we highlight the fate of this extension will lie in the hands of the sub-licensee.
Planning to advance the pipeline in 2016
Newron has now started the Phase II proof-of-concept trial with NW-3509 as an add-on to antipsychotics in schizophrenia; NW-3509 is a probable partnering candidate, given the potential size of the indication. Phase II data could become available in Q416 and we would expect Newron to seek a deal after the publication of this. Sarizotan has been awarded orphan drug status in both the US and Europe for Rett syndrome (RS), and thus a fast-track clinical development and regulatory process is possible. A 24-week, double-blind, placebo-controlled efficacy study (Phase II/III) to investigate breathing disorders is being planned to start in Q216, with results likely in Q317. If successful, the company believes a potential launch mid 2018 is possible given sarizotan’s orphan drug status.
Following the FY15 results we have pushed out our assumption for a safinamide US dyskinesia label expansion to 2020 from 2018. We have not made any other changes to our underlying product assumptions, which include €450m of Xadago peak sales in Parkinson’s disease, in addition to risk-adjusted contributions for Xadago in dyskinesia and the pipeline of orphan opportunities: sarizotan in Rett syndrome; and NW-3509 in schizophrenia, which Newron is planning to partner. We have, however, increased our R&D expense forecasts to reflect investment in sarizotan and NW-3509.
Our valuation has been rolled forward in time and updated for net cash (which comprises last reported gross cash of €40.2m, and last reported total debt of €0.7m relating to a loan from the Italian government, equating to €40.2m, or CHF44.1m at current FX rates of €0.91/CHF). Our revised valuation is CHF504m (previously CHF522m), or CHF35.5 per share.
Exhibit 1: Financial summary
Product |
Indication |
Launch |
Peak sales (€m) |
Value (€m) |
Value (CHFm) |
Probability |
rNPV (€m) |
rNPV (CHFm) |
NPV/share (CHF/share) |
Xadago |
Parkinson's Disease |
2015 |
450 |
264.6 |
354.0 |
90-100% |
252.0 |
337.1 |
23.7 |
|
Dyskinesia |
2020 |
390 |
72.9 |
97.5 |
40% |
29.2 |
39.0 |
2.7 |
Sarizotan |
Rett syndrome |
2018 |
260 |
202.6 |
271.0 |
30% |
53.8 |
72.0 |
5.1 |
NW-3509 |
Schizophrenia |
2019 |
380 |
66.8 |
89.3 |
20% |
8.9 |
11.9 |
0.8 |
Net Cash/(Debt) |
|
|
|
40.2 |
44.1 |
100% |
40.2 |
44.1 |
3.1 |
Valuation |
|
|
|
928.9 |
856.0 |
|
384.0 |
504.1 |
35.5 |
Source: Edison Investment Research
Exhibit 2: Key newsflow in the next 12-18 months
News |
Period |
Comments |
Xadago EU next launches |
2016 |
Pricing and uptake rates. |
Xadago/safinamide US approval |
29 March 2016 |
PDUFA date is 29 March 16; potential launch in H216, subject to securing US partner. |
Xadago/safinamide sublicensing in the US |
2016 |
Zambon is working to sub-license safinamide in ex. EU regions, including the US. |
NW-3509 partnering |
2017 |
A partnering deal could come after the availability of Phase II data. |
Sarizotan PII/III start |
Q216 |
24-week pivotal efficacy study. |
NW-3509 Phase II data |
Q416 |
Will provide first proof of concept data. |
Sarizotan PII/III potential pivotal data |
2017 |
|
Source: Edison Investment Research