2016 interims: Meeting the challenge
As foreshadowed by management, the half year’s trading was heavily influenced by the aftermath of the serious flash flood, in December 2015, which led to the closure of the group’s fabric printing factory for a period of 16 weeks. While production restarted in April 2016, the factory has only recently been restored to full capacity working. In addition to the obvious impact on the profitability of the printing business, group Brand sales were adversely affected by reduced product availability, while the wallcoverings business will also have suffered some loss of business where sales were related to matching fabric sales.
Overall group revenues slipped back by 8.7% to £41.83m, but underlying group profitability benefited from the consolidation of £1.59m of insurance receipts in respect of business interruption reimbursements to cover loss of profits. Adjusted pre-tax profits rose by 2.7% from £3.68m to £3.78m. After a somewhat higher tax charge of 26% (13% in H116), which related largely to prior year adjustments, underlying EPS emerged 13.6% lower, down from 5.35p to 4.62p. As a measure of confidence in the future, the interim dividend was raised by 25% to 0.55p.
Brand revenues fell by 2.0%, including a 6.9% decrease in UK sales. Overseas Brand sales slipped back by 1.7% in constant currency terms, but the impact of the weakness of sterling, especially in relation to the US dollar and the euro, led to a 4.0% revenue increase in reportable currency. There were contrasting performances across overseas markets. Sales to the US were down by 6.5% in constant currency terms, but ahead by 2.5% after currency adjustments. Similarly, a 5.7% increase in sales to Western Europe emerged as a 14.3% increase on conversion into sterling.
There was a useful 16.3% increase in licence income. Important new licensees in the US and China began to contribute, while Japanese licence income (especially for Sanderson and Morris designs) stabilised. With costs firmly under control, Brands division operating profits rose by 8.1% to £3.61m.
Exhibit 3: Interim results
Year to January |
H117 (£000s) |
H116 (£000s) |
Change (%) |
FY16 (£000s) |
Turnover |
|
|
|
|
Brands
|
18,756 13,973 1,114 |
20,155 13,436 958 |
-6.9 +4.0 +16.3 |
39,971 25,888 2,043 |
|
33,843 |
34,549 |
-2.0 |
67,902 |
Manufacturing
|
13,184 1,776 |
16,669 1,978 |
-20.9 -10.2 |
30,920 3,409 |
|
14,960 |
18,647 |
-19.8 |
34,329 |
|
48,803 |
53,196 |
-8.3 |
102,231 |
Intercompany sales |
(6,977) |
(7,362) |
-5.2 |
(14,392) |
|
41,826 |
45,834 |
-8.7 |
87,839 |
Adjusted operating profit |
|
|
|
|
Brands Manufacturing |
3,605 174 |
3,335 1,807 |
+8.1 -90.4 |
8,080 2,482 |
|
3,779 |
5,142 |
-26.5 |
10,562 |
Unallocated costs |
59 |
(1,362) |
|
(1,436) |
|
3,838 |
3,780 |
+1.5 |
9.126 |
Interest |
(60) |
(102) |
|
(179) |
Adjusted pre-tax profit |
3,776 |
3,678 |
+2.7 |
8,947 |
Source: Walker Greenbank company announcements. Note: Figures before exceptional items, share-based payments and defined benefit pension contributions; unallocated cost reduced in FY16 (£1.4m) and H117 (£1.6m) to consolidate other income, related to loss of profit insurance receipts.
Returns from group manufacturing operations reflected the flood problem. Continued progress in wallcoverings was overshadowed by operating losses in fabric printing. Gross divisional revenues slipped by 19.8% to £14.96m, while operating profits were decimated, falling by just over 90% from £1.84m to £0.17m.
There was the usual seasonal increase in working capital requirements ahead of the main selling season, but the group also received substantial payments from its insurers. Net funds increased modestly over the half year, from £2.31m to £2.53m.
Impact of the flood across the group
Exhibit 4: Revenue breakdown
Year to January |
H117 (£000s) |
H116 (£000s) |
Change (%) |
FY16 (£000s) |
Brands |
|
|
|
|
Harlequin Sanderson/Morris Zoffany Others Licence income |
15,556 10,648 6,138 387 1,114 |
16,049 11,029 5,993 520 958 |
-3.1 -3.5 +2.4 -25.6 +16.3 |
31,676 21,503 11,749 931 2,043 |
Total |
33,843 |
34,549 |
-2.0 |
67,902 |
Manufacturing |
|
|
|
|
Standfast Anstey |
5,657 9,303 |
9,615 9,032 |
-41.2 +3.0 |
15,681 18,648 |
Total* |
14,960 |
18,647 |
-19.8 |
34,329 |
Source: Walker Greenbank RNS. *Note: Before internal sales (H116 - £7.4m; H115 - £7.8m; FY15 - £16.4m).
Harlequin, incorporating Scion and Anthology: Harlequin is the most successful and largest of the group’s brands. Its products are aimed at the mid-level of the premium market, with price points ranging from £22-89 per metre/roll. Its collections comprise a distinctive range of contemporary styles, which have enabled the brand to establish itself as the UK leader in its chosen market segment. Harlequin is the leading independent supplier to the John Lewis Partnership (6% of group revenues), but is also gaining further recognition among interior designers and decorators. The brand was extended by the 2012 introduction of Scion, a contemporary brand with slightly lower price points (£12-49), and targeting younger age groups. This was followed last year with another specialist higher market contemporary brand, Anthology (£48-121). Its initial collections comprised textured contemporary wallpapers targeted largely at overseas markets, especially in Eastern Europe and the Far East; this year the brand was extended to include woven fabrics.
The Harlequin group was clearly affected by the poor availability of printed fabrics, with half-year revenues falling by 3.1% to £15.6m. UK revenues slipped by 8.7%, partially balanced by a 6.2% rise in export sales. Within these figures, both Scion and Anthology performed well, with a number of important new collections – the latter, which is largely a wallcoverings brand supplemented only by woven fabrics, will have been unaffected by the flood.
The recent upgrading of the Chelsea Harbour showroom and the improved sales facilities in New York and Dubai should have helped the performance. With the availability of printed fabric now improved again, we look ahead to a much improved second-half performance.
Arthur Sanderson, incorporating Morris & Co: Sanderson is the oldest of the group’s brands, dating back to 1860. It is targeted at the mid- to upper end of the premium market, with price points of up to £116 per metre/roll. It is an internationally recognised brand, with a royal warrant and a distinctive and unique archive. Morris also has a similarly long heritage, based on the skills of the acclaimed designer William Morris. It is also supplied into the mid- to upper end of the premium market and its price points are above those for Sanderson (up to £168). The introduction of Sanderson Home in 2012, targeting a slightly younger market segment (£21-50), represented a key move forward for the brand.
With Sanderson and Morris & Co designs particularly lending themselves to printed, rather than woven fabrics (which provide vertical integration benefits to the upstream manufacturing operations), they will have suffered most from the flood. In this context, a 3.5% reduction in revenues over the half year represents a remarkably good result; the impact of Woodland Walk, a highly successful new collection under the Sanderson label, has been impressive. We look forward optimistically to second half trading.
Zoffany: Zoffany is aimed at the upper end of the premium market. The style tends to be historically based, with many patterns adapted from the furnishings found in a selection of stately homes. It is the youngest of the group’s brands, established just over 30 years ago, but has quickly become recognised for the quality of its rich weaves and elegant designs. Price points start at £35 per metre/roll, but are typically more than double those of other group brands and can be as much as £246 per metre/roll.
With Zoffany fabrics tending to be woven, it was largely unaffected by the flood. Recent action to discontinue a number of marginal collections and changes to the leadership of the design team continue to lift the brand’s appeal. Revenues rose by 2.4% over the half year to £6.1m, with improved performance in overseas markets. We believe that the subtle change in the brand’s direction has much further to go and is likely to continue lifting returns over the next two years.
Standfast & Barracks: Standfast is the last remaining successful UK-based, high-quality fabric printer. It has unique design skills and extensive fabric preparation and finishing processes, which ensure the highest quality of product, combined with the ability to print effectively on a comprehensive range of base fabrics, including cotton, linen, silk, wool and velvet. In addition to supplying the group requirement for printed fabrics, some 55-60% of output is produced for third-party customers, mostly comprising high-quality furnishing fabric houses, such as Osborne & Little and Designers Guild. The progressive introduction of digital printing has added to the flexibility and, hence, the profitability of the plant since 2010. It has also created opportunities to supply product more widely, such as into the apparel industry – the company has supplied Liberty for some years, while discussions are ongoing with a number of other potential customers.
The timing of the flood last December could not have been worse; investment in broadening the plant capabilities had contributed to an 18% rise in revenues in the first half of the previous year, with the promise of more to come. The factory was closed completely for 16 weeks, with production gradually restored over the subsequent six months. The impact on group brands has been described above; for the company itself, revenues fell by 41.2% to £5.7m, with internal sales falling by 35.5% and third-party sales by 49.7%. Walker Greenbank does not disclose profits of individual operations, but there will have been a substantial operating loss for the period.
As indicated at the time of the flood, the business was fully insured for both physical losses and for loss of profit. Payments totalling £12.05m have been received to date, including £11.25m received during the half year. The group half-year results recognised £7.90m of insurance reimbursements, of which £4.56m related to exceptional costs and £3.33m to loss of profits (£1.59m) and exceptional gains for plant and equipment replacement (£1.74m). Further amounts have still to be agreed, notably those related to current year and future (up to two years) loss of profits in the group Brands division.
It is difficult to assess the speed with which third-party business will be regained. Customers will have naturally sourced their requirement from other suppliers – the nature and duration of these alternative arrangements will be quite varied, while there is no guarantee that all lost business will be restored. However, with some of the replacement plant of higher specification than that destroyed in the flood, the company’s ability to respond to opportunities in the market place is considerable. While the group’s third quarter will still be affected, there should be a strong recovery over the final quarter and into 2017.
Anstey Wallpaper: Anstey is one of few remaining UK wallcovering manufacturers, and the larger of two specialists at the quality end of the market. The company is able to use a wide range of paper and vinyl bases and employs a full range of printing techniques to meet the varying needs of a specialist customer base. The plant is equipped to concentrate on shorter runs and is building an impressive third-party customer base (estimated 50% of sales). Investment in recent years has extended capacity, broadened capabilities and introducing digital printing.
Half-year figures show revenue up by 3.0% to £9.3m, with increased internal revenue (including several important new collections for Sanderson and Anthology) rising to compensate for slightly disappointing UK third-party sales, which slipped by 15.3%. We look for another sound performance in the second half.